Some Icons i made

Originally Posted by tarun hari ew. wtf. look at the envelope its horrible and out of proportion. The rest are very average. Look up some icons at www.iconfactory.com to gain some inspiration. They need work!

... now i remember why i dont post here.
mr. better than everyone else has to make ******* comments.

They're great blindchild

Ignore tarun, I wouldn't take offense personally but he does pick up some good points! The envelope is out of proportion imo, other than that, nice job!

They're basic but they work well, nice job

As robson said BC, don't take tarun seriously. He's giving his opinion the same as everyone else don't be so aggressive everytime he does.

I think their alright but could use some work...

[I like them, I think they suit their purose.

SIGH, censorship affects us all..

They look nice! The envelope is a bit to long in lengh but shorten it and it will be perfect. You just have to ignore tarun hes better than everyone else!

yeah he could have just said misproportioned.... i agree with that
but saying... " Ew wtf "
was not necessary

I love the cleanness of them. Nice soft colours you've used too.

~ Joe

If you thought they were perfect blindchild02, then why post them to be reviewed?

Please read the forum descriptions before posting in them

Post your latest creations in here for review by the community.

I can only hope you learn from the constructiveness of my criticism and better your own work. I only post what I honestly think and some take that the right way some don't. Thats fine, those icons will impact people differently my first reaction was "ew, wtf" due to the fact I've seen your previous work and this didn't fit in with the standard I've seen from you before. Now, I don't expect you to take on board what I have said, but my post was made in order for you to bare that in mind.

Tarun, you have built yourself a reputation for leaving comments simular to the ones in these threads, what you said was perfectally honest and blindchild agreed with them however, the way you phrased it made it coem across as being rude and agressive.

I dont dislike you and personally your one of my favorite designers, however your comments do sometimes need to be rephrased to make them sound positive and helpful, afterall not everyone is such a good designer.