Today's Posts Follow Us On Twitter! TFL Members on Twitter  
Forum search: Advanced Search  
Navigation
Marketplace
  Members Login:
Lost password?
  Forum Statistics:
Forum Members: 24,256
Total Threads: 81,171
Total Posts: 566,848
There are 35 users currently browsing (tf).
 
  Our Partners:
 
  TalkFreelance     Design and Development     Graphic Design, Multimedia and Photography     The Gallery Showcase :

How to give constructive criticism

Thread title: How to give constructive criticism
Closed Thread    
    Thread tools Search this thread Display Modes  
07-11-2010, 04:52 PM
#1
Gatt is offline Gatt
Gatt's Avatar
Status: bestyouneverhad
Join date: Jul 2006
Location: Italy
Expertise: Design & Development
Software: Photoshop
 
Posts: 2,061
iTrader: 22 / 100%
 

Gatt is an unknown quantity at this point

Send a message via AIM to Gatt Send a message via Skype™ to Gatt

  Old  How to give constructive criticism

This area of the forum is for people to show case their designs and receive feedback, however what has come to my attention recently is many people give very brief and unhelpful comments which do not help the designer actually further improve their design So here is an example on how to give constructive criticism to help give more detailed feedback.

http://www.battleofart.com/logo/logo1.jpg (Credit to qcssoft)

This is the kind of comment we are trying to avoid
"nice logo but i dont like the text"

Whereas we should look to give them some good comments, some bad comments then say what should be improved.

"I like the design especially the 'A' part, that part actually looks great but I think the orange area isn't needed and it would look better and more sleek without it. I would also like to add how the text you've used for Android just doesn't look professional in my view, try something more like the font Arial and remove the darker shade of grey on the top of the text."

Hope that helps you distinguish between constructive criticism and a brief post which won't help the designer.

Closed Thread    


Thread Tools
Display Modes

  Posting Rules  
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump:
 
  Contains New Posts Forum Contains New Posts   Contains No New Posts Forum Contains No New Posts   A Closed Forum Forum is Closed