It’s simple:
Norted claims back on PayPal, which gets his $250 back which he paid the person he bought the template from, (so now Norted doesn’t lose anything) he then sends me $250 (the correct created) to keep the rights, and therefore is then able to keep the design online. – I will then need to refund the person which I sold the template to (someone completely else) because he no longer wants a design which is getting used. So with that $250 from Norted I would have to give to him. – so actually I havent made any money!

And as mentioned above, Im not making him a new design, As I refuse to work with a company who is still hosting my ripped design.

But at the end of the day, hes not refunding me, hes not claiming back on paypal, and therefore I will have to refund the correct owner of t19, so I will be down $250.00 - So hes a scammer.

I honestly don’t think your helping yourself here Fjeddy.