I agree, people some times only post "i love it" or "i hate it" they never go into depth answers and tell the people on talkfreelance why they beleive this. and the idea of:

At least once per day, could every member write a post (new thread, or reply) of at least 100 words (the length of the paragraph above) AND/OR spend at least 5 minutes planning a structured reply. The two generally go hand-in-hand: Planned replies take time and have length.

i would certainly agree with this as it can be very good material for other members to read, and the basic "i like it" could be changed into "i like it because.....blah blah blah"

Thanks for your comments Salathe, and i would also like to be reading your future posts